The Good
Yeah, we got mentioned in a Tweet – admit it, we all love to be noticed. But today kind of threw me for a loop. I saw this tweet and of course was happy – I liked it, I retweeted it and threw a tweet back thanking them, you know because good social manners are important!
The Bad
After all this was said and done, for some reason I was inclined to click the link – even though I can see what they shared – I was drawn to that little ow.ly link that was screaming CLICK ME. So I did and what I found initially scared the hell out of me – I thought we had been hacked. I click the link only to see my page – my content with a big ugly ad in the lower left – you can see a screenshot of my worst nightmare below.
That big blue arrow is pointing to the ad that was somehow placed on my website without my knowledge – when you look at that ad you can see the name of the sharer “CrowdFund Genius” and in the upper right is the name Snip.ly – that is the company that makes all this possible.
The Ugly
Imagine a world where anyone can see a page/post on your website that has a lot of shares or comments and then can add their OWN call to action button, sales pitch or form to your web page to try and lure that traffic to their own website – or to turn your readers into customers, all without your permission.
That world is real – and it is here now, thanks to Snip.ly.
It is easy to use and the basic plan is free making it a popular option for those get rich quick schemes and non-ethical brands who are looking for a short cut to build exposure. We are NOT implying that every business using Snip.ly is unethical – or scammy – but because of the ease of use, low cost and so many wanting to earn a quick buck, we do see this as a big issue for website owners.
Snip.ly offers several plans and the more you pay them – the more options you have in regards to ad design and placement, meaning the look and feel is controlled by the ad placer – not you.
Why We Think This Is The Worst Idea Ever
There are so many reasons we think Snip.ly should not be used but here are a few of our main concerns:
1) The false assumption of readers that a website is ENDORSING a brand that has hijacked the post. When an ad is shown on a page it is considered an endorsement of sorts – as a website owner you would not have an ad for a product/service you would not use would you? That is what your visitors will assume – so this is giving a false sense of security to visitors – ultimately which can affect your REPUTATION!
Many are not familiar with Snip.ly yet and will not be aware that you did not control that content – this is NOT a good thing!
2) The risk of losing readers to this ad is also an issue. The link in the ad will take them off-site and more often than not, they do not come back to your website. While we understand that it is the ad sharer bringing in the traffic – we still do not want them clicking off the website once they are there!
3) The use of your name, logo and business model to promote their own service or product without your consent borderlines on illegal in our opinion.
We are not alone in our thinking – this is a great post by Plagiarism Today that goes a little deeper into the legal side of things with this whole business model.
Why Would Anyone Use This?
Great question. Let’s say there is a website I stalk – we will use a good friend, Fidose of Reality as an example. I know she gets a lot of traffic – I know people really engage with the website – so I want a piece of that to market my web design business.
I jump over to Snip.ly – enter my CTA information – enter a URL from Fidose of Reality that I want to have my CTA appear on and voila – instant traffic. I chose this post because it talks about “Making Money with Blogging” – and maybe people will think – hmmm I should probably update my website – and there I am! Cool right?
See where we are going with this? You have NO CONTROL over what is being shown on your website.
Faking An Endorsement
Alternatively, we have seen cases where companies are using this with FAKE personas – stealing the names and faces of the biggest industry names to place in these ads so unsuspecting visitors think it is a valuable proposition.
I can easily add a name like Victoria Stillwell with her image and name with a link to a scammy affiliate link to a dog house building blue print. I can steal Jeff Bullas’ image and name and sell social media services – it is just all around a scary thing. Those ads can be made to replicate ANYTHING.
Wait – So My Page Will Always Have This Ad On It?
NO! The page will ONLY show the ad if it as accessed with the Snip.ly link.
So – in a more broad sense, this is not like someone is taking over your website. But – the negatives to this approach can still harm you. If it is a larger group that is doing PPC or large social outreach you never know who is clicking on the link and seeing your content with this ad you did not authorize.
Basically, what it comes down to is that others are using YOUR content to promote their own related services or products – and to us that is NOT OK!
But They Are Sending Me Traffic Aren’t They? Why Is That Bad?
Technically, yes they are sending traffic to your website. And maybe, like in my experience – it is not some horribly scammy company.
I looked up CrowdFund Genius – the company that utilized the service to post an ad over my content – and they seem OK. But they do offer some services that I offer and I in no way shape or form want to be affiliated with a company I know NOTHING about – and I sure as hell do not want our competition linking to us to promote their services.
Because we work largely in Non-Profit Web Design – we do not want the first engagement with our website to be from a Snip.ly url since we then have no control of what the page is promoting. If this company wants to promote their fundraising services – they are likely to want social sharing from important people in the non-profit community – the same community we engage with and market to.
EXAMPLE: What if they did outreach to some major non-profit professionals who have large followings on social media. The post then gets lots of shares because it looks like a great article for non-profits to read. Yes, this is all good for us, so far. But then they get to the site – and their FIRST interaction with us is a huge ad for a competitor, not really what I want them to see. But even worse – what if that ad was for porn or hooka pipes or some other industry that would make us look bad. We can probably kiss them goodbye as a potential client forever after that.
How Can I Tell If Someone Is “Sniplying” My Website?
We only found out about this because they happened to tag us on Twitter – for which I actually commend them – I would think most Snip.ly users are not tagging the brands they are stealing content from.
The only way we were able to determine if there are Snip.ly links pointing to a website was in Google Analytics.
If you got to ALL TRAFFIC > CHANNELS > OTHER you should be able to see them in there if there are actually links. if you do not have an other referral source then you have no Snip.ly links linking to you.
Stop Snip.ly From Appearing On Your Website
I would hope after reading this most of you will want to protect your websites from this hijacking. The easiest way to stop it is to install the following plugin created by a team that is also pretty fed up with Snip.ly.
Download Snip.ly Buster by Warfare Plugins
Your Thoughts?
While we know everyone is entitled to their opinion – we clearly think this is a horrible idea for most website owners – but we would love to hear your thoughts about Snip.ly and engage in a conversation about this type of marketing.
Have you used Snip.ly successfully? Is this something you actually would consider implementing?
Or, will you be running to download the plugin because you think this is as unethical as we do?
We are all ears and ready to have our minds changed if you think we are wrong!
As a small business e-commerce site owner that needs quality content I think Sniply is a good idea. If I didn’t use it to curate content I’d be working 18 hours a day 7 days a week. Who can do all the stuff that’s required to run an e-commerce website and also research, write, edit, proofread, upload, and refresh quality content? Superman I’d guess. Nobody human I know. However, if I saw a Sniply link on my site I might think differently. It’s a tough call. Small business owners can only wear so many hats and Sniply is very useful. Like it or hate it’s probably here to stay. Customers and Google demand quality content so owners provide it or they’re out of business.
What about small business owners who work 18 hours a day to create content? It’s OK for you then to hijack our hard work to send yourself leads? Sniply is useful only for people who lack ethics.
This debate is pretty silly.
Your content is being shared; all your links are still there, it’s exposure. I first found Sniply in my analytics, I got flooded with referral traffic from ClickFunnels because they used Sniply to link to an article I wrote about affiliate marketing on our “Hobo with a Laptop” blog. I was honoured and happy they chose to share my content with their followers because we got a ton of traffic.
There are a few ways to mitigate Sniply (and stop being traumatised by it).
1. Make amazing content and have your own clear CTA; make Sniply traffic choose your CTA over the Sniply one.
2. Use Sniply yourself. It’s not so dirty. I see you hardly use social at all! Huge lost opportunity there.
3. Opt out of Sniply directly: https://snip.ly/publishers/
In the end, I went with a similar service called Back.ly, much cheaper for my work-related needs.
ISPs, router manufacturers and even Amazon Kindles have been manipulating website traffic to inject their own ads for years. I’m not a lawyer and can’t give legal advice, but I think Backly and Sniply are perfectly legal.
If people are using Sniply to point their following to your website, take it as a compliment.
I would not call any debate silly – you have your thoughts we have ours. I do NOT take it as a complement that someone wants to take my work and put some kind of crappy cheesy overlay on it. It demeans my brand and makes it appear as if I am somehow promoting that item/service. No one has the right to use my content without my permission. If this is acceptable to you – than good for you, but I work too hard to create content that I feel is valuable and do not want some other person taking advantage of it. And yes, we do not use social that much – because we are too busy working on client projects! 🙂 Glad you enjoy Sniply —-
Interesting conversation. I never thought of it that way. If we write a blog post and link to someone, whether it is a company or another blog post, we often use the sniply link so that 1) people will remember who sent them to the link and 2) so we can see whether including that link was effective. From our perspective, it was a compliment since we would never link to anything that was not relevant and or helpful to our readers. It’s also a way for people to get a backlink, which helps their search ranking. We thought it was a win-win for both sides – traffic and a backlink for the other person and helpful info for our readers.
As a blog owner myself, I do understand your point but I don’t think you are 100% right.
They are not stealing content, they are stealing ad/banner space
But still, why shouldn’t they get some incentives for sharing someone’s website?
It’s 100% their traffic after all.
Why should the website owner get everything?
It’s OK for you when someone shares your website so you get more traffic and eventually earn more money,
but why don’t you pay them for every time they share it? Or, at least, let them earn some other way.
And if their traffic likes your website, they’ll come back again without their link, so it will 100% win for you.
Would you rather have:
1. No one shares your website because you are cheap/selfish, or
2. Some people share your website because they get some reward for their effort
Thanks for your thoughts! Everyone of course has their own opinions, but I think very differently from you. I do not want my content shared with their ads on it. It is a point of branding and that I own my content and should be able to control HOW it is shared. I am not asking them to share it – they are taking and sharing it – I want my content shared because I invest hours into every post I write – why should someone else benefit from that?
I completely agree with all your points. As a content marketing professional, I have no problems sharing other people’s content. Content curation, after all, is part of it. What I don’t agree and have an issue with is when people take the easy route and just slap their branding and CTA wherever they can. It’s an insult to the ones who spent hours creating valuable content.
If you truly want to share content that is related to what you’re doing, create your own post —show that you’re an authority in the space— and maybe provide a linkback to the source as an added resource for your audience. OR just share the post! Why go through all the trouble of creating a snip.ly if the intention was merely to provide additional value to your audience?
Just my thoughts. 🙂