OK – we know how it goes. You started your website years ago, and now you are looking back and cringing at what you are seeing. Did I really write that? Those spelling errors cannot be mine! Wait, those are not even sentences! YIKES! So you scramble to delete it all before someone actually sees it now that you have grown – but WAIT.
How you delete your old content — or not delete that content can affect your readers experience and your organic traffic. So hold your horses and let’s think about this strategically. (I know scary word – but we will try to make it easy – scouts honor!)
PROS OF REMOVING CONTENT
- Up to date and relevant content
- Content will be more search friendly
- Improvement of organic rank
CONS OF REMOVING CONTENT
- May lose inbound links
- Possible loss of social signals
- Can affect usability if page not found
So Should I Remove Old Content?
Maybe Yes. Maybe No.
Ok, not the answer you wanted – but really – it depends on a lot of factors. When you are considering removing content from your website – here are a few things to ask yourself about each page.
1) Is the content useful to your reader? If it is useful, educational or informational and just outdated – we say keep it and update it. If it is a contest, promotional or lacking in real value – it is probably safe to remove it.
2) Are there backlinks to the specific page? Good backlinks are hard to find and critical for SEO success – if your page has backlinks to it – we suggest keeping it and modifying the content to make it more useful and updated.
3) Is the page getting traffic? Checking analytics will give you this important information. If there is a decent amount of traffic – again, you may want to keep it and repurpose it somehow.
OK, But How Can I Analyze My Pages To Get The Data?
- If you have Google Analytics installed – our first recommendation would be to visit Panguin. This is a great tool that will look at your analytical data and will match your traffic against dates of various algorithm updates like Panda (which focuses on site quality) and Penguin (which focus on links). If you notice a big drop after a specific update – that will be the first step into better understanding what you need to do to improve your website. If you see a big drop in traffic after a Panda update – then you know you have work to do on your content!
- Review your Google Analytics data. Find the pages that are drawing the least amount of visits. If you have specific pages you would like to remove – you can search for them in analytics to determine if they are receiving traffic. In analytics you will want to go to the BEHAVIOR area then SITE CONTENT and ALL PAGES. Then you can sort by Page Views to see how many views a page gets.
- To see if your page has backlinks you can get a quick overview at Backlink Watch or Backlink Checker. Unfortunately, this is one area that is lacking in free services – so we would use both tools for each page just to double check. Enter the page you are considering removing – if there are links, and they are good ones – keep it! (Keep in mind different back link checkers return different results so if they vary that is OK!). Open Site Explorer by Moz would be a great investment if you are serious about SEO and improving your backlinks.
In the example below you can see we have many pages that get only a few hits a month. There is no “magic number” as to when to delete a page – it will be relative to the traffic you get. If you are getting 5K visits a month and your page only gets 3 hits and is old and out dated – then we would say it is safe to remove.
But if you get 100 visits a month and it gets 3 hits a month and is outdated – you may want to spend some time updating and improving the content and try to get more visits.
So I Now Know That I am Getting Traffic & Have Backlinks To An Old Page – Now What?
Well, this is good news! If you have a page that makes you insane and you want to get rid of it because it annoys you with its bad content – but you see it gets traffic and has backlinks it is time to put on your thinking cap.
Look at the content and see how you can repurpose it so it maintains a similar content type but in a way you can entertain, teach or inform. It is was an old contest – what did you give away? Can you somehow take that prize and turn it into an educational post about something related to that prize. If it was a blog crawl post Wordless Wednesday for example) – can you remove the notations about the Wordless Wednesday and revise the content to be more useful to your reader?
There Are No Backlinks or Page Visits – What Are My Options For Page Removal?
If you have a page that you are sure has no traffic, the content is poor and there are no backlinks- then lets delete it. If it is showing in search results (which if you are not getting much content it probably isn’t) – eventually Google will see it is gone and will remove it from the search results. If you just delete a page, then if someone should land on it the user will get the dreaded 404 error. Google will see this – and will come back and check a few times to make sure it is not coming back – but eventually remove it.
We highly recommend a custom 404 page be built for every website that helps users find the content they want if they should land on a page that no longer exists.
2) 301 REDIRECT
We recommend a 301 redirect if you want to delete a page that has some traffic, has backlinks or is in the search results. A 301 redirect will bring your users to a new page if they follow a link to the page you want to remove – so you want to make sure you bring them to a related post. If you had a post about a contest for a cooking tool – maybe link to a recipe that uses that cooking tool. A 301 redirect is typically done via your .htacess file but if you use Wordpress you can also use a plugin like Simple 301 Redirects.
Be sure to review this great post on properly using 301 redirects before you implement yours!
3) IMPROVE THE CONTENT
If you have a page that is getting traffic and has rank and has the potential to be “revived” – then this is the optimal option. Modify your content to be as in depth as possible – add strong images and rename the page title and you can reuse the post and offer your readers something great. You can even change the date of the post and add a note that says “updated xx/xx/xxxx” – this will let readers now you keep this page updated. You can also change the actual “post date” of the post itself which can help Google see it as new content which can help you in the search results.
What Happens When You No-Index An Existing Post?
If you no-index a page that is already indexed – it should eventually be removed from the search engines. The search engines will need to re-crawl your page to be able to see the no-index code that has been applied. So, depending on your crawl rate – it could take a few days or a few weeks.
How Do I Know How Often Google Crawls My Website?
Again, this is where Webmaster Tools comes in super handy! By visiting the Crawl section in your Webmaster Tools – you can find some very important information that will help you understand your site and may even find issues that you should be aware of.
In the example below you can see this website gets a visit from Google everyday – some days they crawl a lot more than others – and those spikes in the graph may reflect images, uploads as well as standard pages. You also want to keep an eye if Google Bots are coming too often and using too much bandwidth which can reflect on your site speed!
If you feel uncertain about when you page will be visited by Google and want to speed it up – you can visit the Fetch As Google link! This will send a gentle nudge to Google to come visit your website. You will want to put the actual page you want them to visit in this tool.
While we hope this article will help you streamline your content and improve your website – we know it can still be confusing! If you have questions – just let us know and we will be glad to help!